Sean Taylor?

I think we should... I mean, its unfair that I lose a 96 because of something outside of the league. But what do you guys think?

If you did that you should also create Darrien Nash, Marquise Hill, and the CB from the Broncos, his name slips my rind right now.

mksadng wrote:

If you did that you should also create Darrien Nash, Marquise Hill, and the CB from the Broncos, his name slips my rind right now.

Darrent Williams. And I could probably do that if the GMs wanted to... I mean I'd have

Nash - 71
Hill - 68
Williams - 83

So other than Williams I don't think the others are impact players.

SoxNats08 wrote:

mksadng wrote:

If you did that you should also create Darrien Nash, Marquise Hill, and the CB from the Broncos, his name slips my rind right now.

Darrent Williams. And I could probably do that if the GMs wanted to... I mean I'd have

Nash - 71
Hill - 68
Williams - 83

So other than Williams I don't think the others are impact players.

WAY to low. He was coming into his own next to Bailey. He should be a 88+ IMO if you do this

Vhawk413 wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

mksadng wrote:

If you did that you should also create Darrien Nash, Marquise Hill, and the CB from the Broncos, his name slips my rind right now.

Darrent Williams. And I could probably do that if the GMs wanted to... I mean I'd have

Nash - 71
Hill - 68
Williams - 83

So other than Williams I don't think the others are impact players.

WAY to low. He was coming into his own next to Bailey. He should be a 88+ IMO if you do this

eh thats a bit too kind... what was he in the last madden, 85? fine id make him an 86

If we recreate sean taylor then people could start complaining about guys like steve mcnair, who might last into the second season of 08 but retired in real life. Same goes for ogden (pending if he retires). But recreating all those guys would be stupid. I say if we switch to 09 then we have to be commited to it and not to mess around with the rosters. That might just be a biased opinion since you're in my division, but it would be stupid to alter rosters because a real life incident. Arent we supposed to be modelling this league realistically?

If you have Sean Taylor then you might as well create Michael Vick sure its sad to see players killed and locked up but there should be no reason to have him/ them in madden when there not there in the NFL anymore. Lets keep it real.

SliverNBlackAttack wrote:

If you have Sean Taylor then you might as well create Michael Vick sure its sad to see players killed and locked up but there should be no reason to have him/ them in madden when there not there in the NFL anymore. Lets keep it real.

i agree

SoxNats08 wrote:

Vhawk413 wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

mksadng wrote:

If you did that you should also create Darrien Nash, Marquise Hill, and the CB from the Broncos, his name slips my rind right now.

Darrent Williams. And I could probably do that if the GMs wanted to... I mean I'd have

Nash - 71
Hill - 68
Williams - 83

So other than Williams I don't think the others are impact players.

WAY to low. He was coming into his own next to Bailey. He should be a 88+ IMO if you do this

eh thats a bit too kind... what was he in the last madden, 85? fine id make him an 86

He was an 85 and what 22-23. And he got A LOT better. I would bet he would have been a 90 on the next year had he not gotten shot. He was going to be a stud CB and was MUCH better next to Champ than Dre Bly was and Bly was a 92

I vote to put Taylor in, it sorta is a kind of respect in my mind. Although it does benefit you quite a bit to do that.

Brianeal23 wrote:

I vote to put Taylor in, it sorta is a kind of respect in my mind. Although it does benefit you quite a bit to do that.

i know, which is why i made it a poll and not an admin decision

Brianeal23 wrote:

I vote to put Taylor in, it sorta is a kind of respect in my mind. Although it does benefit you quite a bit to do that.

Then if he gets voted in then there will be all havoc for Michael Vick to be voted in D. Williams to be voted in and all of them. I would want Warren Sapp voted in as well. It shouldnt be that way. If you respect what Taylor was let him rest in peace.

SilverNBlackAttack wrote:

Brianeal23 wrote:

I vote to put Taylor in, it sorta is a kind of respect in my mind. Although it does benefit you quite a bit to do that.

Then if he gets voted in then there will be all havoc for Michael Vick to be voted in D. Williams to be voted in and all of them. I would want Warren Sapp voted in as well. It shouldnt be that way. If you respect what Taylor was let him rest in peace.

I don't agree with that statement, but yes. I think we should just let it go.

superskin6 wrote:

I don't agree with that statement, but yes. I think we should just let it go.

Says the kid who put Sean Taylor on the trading block the day he died in the VNFL.

Steve_Smith_#12 wrote:

superskin6 wrote:

I don't agree with that statement, but yes. I think we should just let it go.

Says the kid who put Sean Taylor on the trading block the day he died in the VNFL.

I would also have to say no, on creating a sean taylor.

i say no unless jim brown can be created onto the browns

I want Pacman Jones!!!!!!

SoxNats08 wrote:

I think we should... I mean, its unfair that I lose a 96 because of something outside of the league. But what do you guys think?

If thats you're reason, than no. If you wanted to honor his memory by keeping his career alive in our league than I'd probably say yes.

Like Dan Marino

If you make him, create favre, cuz i know madden will have him retireing this yr

Yes that would be one sick secondary with him in it. Taylor and Landry means beast mode now.

agsoldier wrote:

Yes that would be one sick secondary with him in it. Taylor and Landry means beast mode now.

Congrats!, you win the award for the most useless bump in the forum!

eaglesfan90 wrote:

agsoldier wrote:

Yes that would be one sick secondary with him in it. Taylor and Landry means beast mode now.

Congrats!, you win the award for the most useless bump in the forum!