madden 09 ratings

some came out alrady


http://www.sportsgamer.com/content/1603/madden-09-quarterback-ratings/

ya i saw these posted on FF

btw sims it goes in here

vince young was overated

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

SoxNats08 wrote:

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

no he shouldnt. young should be lower but jason is just fine. he had a 77 passer rating. and his teammate todd collins was better last year.
Now i have a problem with aaron rogers being 83.

is rivers that good of a QB?

how does dixon have 60 speed? thats 1 more than manning... he should have atleast 80

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

no he shouldnt. young should be lower but jason is just fine. he had a 77 passer rating. and his teammate todd collins was better last year.
Now i have a problem with aaron rogers being 83.

Campbell >>>> Rogers

SoxNats08 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

no he shouldnt. young should be lower but jason is just fine. he had a 77 passer rating. and his teammate todd collins was better last year.
Now i have a problem with aaron rogers being 83.

Campbell >>>> Rogers

I agree with you, but i think taht rogerws whould be like 78 79 range and campbell hshould stay.

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

no he shouldnt. young should be lower but jason is just fine. he had a 77 passer rating. and his teammate todd collins was better last year.
Now i have a problem with aaron rogers being 83.

Campbell >>>> Rogers

I agree with you, but i think taht rogerws whould be like 78 79 range and campbell hshould stay.

Jason is MUCH better then the stats show. And he can throw the ball like, 80 yards, so his arm strenght is WAY underrated. But XBox360 ratings always screw Washington.

superskin6 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

no he shouldnt. young should be lower but jason is just fine. he had a 77 passer rating. and his teammate todd collins was better last year.
Now i have a problem with aaron rogers being 83.

Campbell >>>> Rogers

I agree with you, but i think taht rogerws whould be like 78 79 range and campbell hshould stay.

Jason is MUCH better then the stats show. And he can throw the ball like, 80 yards, so his arm strenght is WAY underrated. But XBox360 ratings always screw Washington.

Thank you

IMO the QBs should be as follows:

Grossman 76
Palmer 96
Edwards 81
Cutler 85
Anderson 88
Garcia 89
Leinart 83
Rivers 89
Huard 80
Manning 98
Romo 94
McCown 78
McNabb 91
Ryan 83
Smith 79
Manning 89
Garrard 91
Pennington 80
Kitna 84
Rodgers 80
Delhomme 87
Brady 99
Russell 83
Bulger 91
Flacco 81
Campbell 85
Brees 92
Hasselbeck 93
Roethlisberger 92
Schaub 85
Young 83
Jackson 80

superskin6 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

no he shouldnt. young should be lower but jason is just fine. he had a 77 passer rating. and his teammate todd collins was better last year.
Now i have a problem with aaron rogers being 83.

Campbell >>>> Rogers

I agree with you, but i think taht rogerws whould be like 78 79 range and campbell hshould stay.

Jason is MUCH better then the stats show. And he can throw the ball like, 80 yards, so his arm strenght is WAY underrated. But XBox360 ratings always screw Washington.

jason hasnt shown me anything. he is right where he should be

SimsZilla wrote:

superskin6 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

no he shouldnt. young should be lower but jason is just fine. he had a 77 passer rating. and his teammate todd collins was better last year.
Now i have a problem with aaron rogers being 83.

Campbell >>>> Rogers

I agree with you, but i think taht rogerws whould be like 78 79 range and campbell hshould stay.

Jason is MUCH better then the stats show. And he can throw the ball like, 80 yards, so his arm strenght is WAY underrated. But XBox360 ratings always screw Washington.

jason hasnt shown me anything. he is right where he should be

Umm have you watched any Skins games?

SoxNats08 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

superskin6 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

no he shouldnt. young should be lower but jason is just fine. he had a 77 passer rating. and his teammate todd collins was better last year.
Now i have a problem with aaron rogers being 83.

Campbell >>>> Rogers

I agree with you, but i think taht rogerws whould be like 78 79 range and campbell hshould stay.

Jason is MUCH better then the stats show. And he can throw the ball like, 80 yards, so his arm strenght is WAY underrated. But XBox360 ratings always screw Washington.

jason hasnt shown me anything. he is right where he should be

Umm have you watched any Skins games?

yes, and he is a decent QB who will be good real soon, just not yet

Jason Campbell's rating should be at least 88.
Denis Dixon's speed needs to be higher.
Vince Young's overall rating needs to be lower.
Tarvaris Jackson's speed is overated.
Brett Favre should have accuracy of 0.
Tom Brady's arm strength should be 90 or so.

Jason Campbell's rating should be at least 88.- WRONG
Denis Dixon's speed needs to be higher.- CORRECT
Vince Young's overall rating needs to be lower.- CORRECT
Tarvaris Jackson's speed is overated.- CORRECT(but he sucks at passing so they had to give him something)
Brett Favre should have accuracy of 0.- wrong
Tom Brady's arm strength should be 90 or so.- ehhhh maybe like 96-97 but he shouldnt be higher then Jamarcus

yayanjl wrote:

Jason Campbell's rating should be at least 88.
Denis Dixon's speed needs to be higher.
Vince Young's overall rating needs to be lower.
Tarvaris Jackson's speed is overated.
Brett Favre should have accuracy of 0.
Tom Brady's arm strength should be 90 or so.

Campbell should not be 88. 85-86 is what he should be. Favre isn't in the game I don't believe, and Brady's strength should be 95ish.

SoxNats08 wrote:

SimsZilla wrote:

SoxNats08 wrote:

PatsDynasty wrote:

vince young was overated

agreed i think he should be like an 82 or an 83

jason campbell should definitely be an 85... he is much better than young

no he shouldnt. young should be lower but jason is just fine. he had a 77 passer rating. and his teammate todd collins was better last year.
Now i have a problem with aaron rogers being 83.

Campbell >>>> Rogers

Yeah thats almost a fair statment. How much has Jason played compaired to Aaron?

And I agree Sims, idk why hes 83, hes never realy played

Well Jason is actually an 84, these are wrong.

SoxNats08 wrote:

Well Jason is actually an 84, these are wrong.

yeah sims cant you do anything right? lol